Shop

Stores

Bakery

With 25 local bakeries represented under one roof, why go anywhere else? Whether the indulgence of our moist tiramisu catches your fancy or our buttery and flaky croissants make your mouth water, there's no doubt that our selection is tastefully tempting.

Our fresh baked goods include, but are certainly not limited to delightful sweets, savory panini and fresh baked cookies, doughnuts, crusty breads, cakes, pies, bagels, specialty tortes and jumbo muffins, that are available everyday! Take in the delicious smells of our mouth-watering displays or talk with one of our Confections Designers if a custom creation is on the tip of your tongue.

About



The Best Selection of Beef in Town!


  • Local & Sustainable

  • Kobe*

  • Prime

  • Dry-Aged*

  • Choice Black Angus

  • Grass-Fed

  • Organic

*Metcalfe’s Hilldale only.



Sustainability is a complex issue. “You can’t for example say that all farmed fish is good or bad, or that eating certain species is bad and eating others is good. Our goal here is to educate our customers.” Leah Caplan, Chief Food Officer.

local meat at Metcalfes

Best in town?
You tell us!


Carl's Cakes


Contact our bakery department for all of our fabulous flavors and sizes, including local Carl’s Cakes at Hilldale.

REUSE & CHOOSE

Keep reusing those shopping bags! Take .10¢ off your purchase or give .10¢ to our Charity of the Month:

January:
Keep WI Warm
Salvation Army

February:
American Red Cross

March:
Muscular Dystrophy Association

April:
WI Coalition Against Domestic Violence
Sojourner Family Peace Center

May:
Special Olympics Wisconsin

June:
Clean Lakes Alliance
Mental Health America of Wisconsin

July:
Boys & Girls Club

August:
Ronald McDonald House

September:
Humane Society

October:
Susan G. Komen

November:
Second Harvest Food Bank
Feeding America

December:
American Family Children’s Hospital
Children’s Hospital of MKE
 

Metcalfe’s Floral guarantees more than 50 varieties of premium quality flowers and plants everyday (at grocery store prices)!

  • We Deliver
  • Open 24 Hours*
  • Walk-in Cooler*
  • 5-Day Flower Guarantee
  • Award-winning design

*Metcalfe’s Hilldale only.